
Here are annuities explained in one sentence: you give an insurance company money, all at once or over time, and it promises to pay you back later, often as income you cannot outlive.
That promise is the whole point. It is also why annuities are so often misunderstood.
At Blue Peak Risk Advisors, an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, we see the same pattern with people close to retirement. They hear “guaranteed income” or “no market losses” and stop asking questions. This guide covers the questions to ask before you sign anything.
What Is an Annuity and How Does It Work?
An annuity is a contract with a life insurance company. It has two stages.
In the first stage, you put money in and it grows tax-deferred. This means you most often owe no income tax on the earnings until you take money out. In the second stage, you take withdrawals or turn the balance into income. That income can last a set number of years or for life.
Timing is the first way annuities differ. An immediate annuity starts paying soon after you buy it with a lump sum. A deferred annuity waits, sometimes for many years, so the balance can grow first. The second difference, and the bigger one, is how the money grows: fixed, indexed, or variable.
One more point: an annuity is an insurance contract, not a bank account. Fixed and indexed annuities depend on the insurer’s ability to pay claims. They are not FDIC-insured.
Before you buy, check the company’s financial strength rating and your state guaranty limits, which vary by state. You can read more about our annuity options here.
Fixed vs Indexed vs Variable Annuities

The real difference between the three types is who carries the investment risk: you or the insurer.
| Fixed | Indexed | Variable | |
| How it grows | Insurer declares an interest rate | Credits are linked to a market index, such as the S&P 500, under set rules | Money is invested in subaccounts, similar to mutual funds |
| Can you lose principal? | Not from market moves, if held to term | Not from index losses, if held to term | Yes |
| Upside | Limited to the declared rate | Limited by caps, participation rates or spreads | Not capped |
| Main trade-off | Rate can reset after the guarantee period | Rules are complex and can change | Higher fees and market risk |
Fixed annuities: work like a CD from an insurer. The company sets a rate for a set time, often several years. Then it may reset the rate. They suit people who want steady, predictable growth above all else.
Indexed annuities: are where a fixed vs indexed annuity comparison gets tricky. Your money is not in the market. Instead, the insurer credits interest based on how an index does. But a cap or participation rate limits how much of that gain you get.
The SEC has warned that these limits can cut your returns much like a fee, even when a product says it has no fee. Always ask what the cap is today and if the insurer can change it.
Variable annuities: let you pick investment options, so your balance goes up and down with them. That means you can lose money. They are securities, so they come with a prospectus and are sold by agents with the right license. Ask any agent which annuity types they are licensed to sell.
What Annuities Cost: Fees, Surrender Charges and Taxes
Annuity costs are easy to miss. They are often built into the contract instead of billed to you.
Fees: Fixed and indexed annuities most often have no visible yearly fee on the base contract. The cost is built into the rate or caps you get. Add-on riders, like guaranteed income benefits, often have their own charge.
Variable annuities show their costs more openly. The SEC’s investor bulletin gives examples of a mortality and expense charge of about 1.25% a year, admin fees of about 0.15% a year or a flat $25 to $50, plus fund fees and any rider fees.
Surrender charges. If you take out more than the contract allows during the surrender period, you pay a penalty. The SEC says this charge often drops a little each year over several years. Ask for the exact schedule in writing. Also ask how much you can take out each year with no charge.
Most contracts also have a free-look period, often 10 to 30 days. During that time, you can cancel and get a refund.
Taxes. Earnings are not taxed while they stay in the annuity. When you take them out, they are most often taxed as ordinary income, not at the lower capital gains rate.
Taking money out before age 59½ can also add a 10% federal tax on the taxable part, with some exceptions. The IRS points readers to Publication 575 for annuity rules.
If you buy an annuity inside an IRA, keep in mind that the IRA already defers tax. So the annuity should earn its place through its guarantees, not its tax benefits. A CPA can tell you how this applies to you.
Who Should Buy an Annuity, and Who Should Not

An annuity tends to fit people who want guaranteed income for key bills on top of Social Security or a pension.
It can help if you worry about outliving your savings, or if you have already maxed out your 401(k) and IRA and want more tax-deferred savings. It can also suit someone close to retirement who cares more about protecting savings than chasing growth.
It tends to be a poor fit if you may need the money during the surrender period, if you do not have an emergency fund yet, or if your main goal is the most long-term growth.
Be extra careful if someone suggests replacing an annuity or life policy you already have. A new contract often starts a new surrender period, and the new product may not be better.
Annuities also solve a different problem than life insurance. If you want to replace income for your family if you die, a policy like term life insurance is often the better tool.
Our term vs whole life comparison explains the difference. If you want lifelong coverage with cash value, read our guide to indexed universal life insurance.
Before you commit, ask these six questions:
- What is the surrender period, and what is the charge each year?
- How exactly is my interest or credit calculated, and can the cap or rate change?
- What are all the fees, including riders?
- How strong is the insurer’s financial rating?
- What does my beneficiary receive if I die early?
- Is this agent licensed in my state, and how are they paid on this sale?
An independent agent can compare many insurers instead of selling one company’s product. You can request a quote or a review at any time. Our life insurance page lists the other coverage we offer.
Frequently Asked Questions About Annuities
Are annuities a good investment?
An annuity is better seen as an insurance product for steady income than as a growth investment.
It can be a good fit if you want guaranteed income or want to protect your savings, and you accept limited growth and limited access to your money. If you want the most growth or easy access, other tools often fit better.
What is the difference between a fixed and an indexed annuity?
A fixed annuity earns a rate the insurer sets. An indexed annuity earns interest tied to a market index, but caps, participation rates, or spreads limit how much of the gain you get. Neither one puts your savings at risk from market losses if you keep the contract to the end of its term.
Can you lose money in an annuity?
You can lose money in a variable annuity because it is invested in the market. In fixed and indexed annuities, your savings are not tied to market losses. But taking money out early can lead to surrender charges, and you depend on the insurer’s ability to pay.
How are annuity withdrawals taxed?
Earnings are most often taxed as ordinary income when you take them out. Taking money out before age 59½ can add a 10% federal tax on the taxable part, with some exceptions. Talk with a tax expert before you withdraw.
What happens to an annuity when the owner dies?
It depends on the contract. Many annuities pay a death benefit to your beneficiary. But some income options, like a life-only payout, stop when you die. Pick your payout option and beneficiary with an agent who explains these trade-offs clearly.
If you are thinking about an annuity, talk to a licensed Blue Peak agent for a plain-English comparison with no pressure to buy.